The exterminating angel
Luis Buñuel at the Harvard Film Archive
by Steve Vineberg
"THE SUBVERSIVE CHARM OF LUIS BUÑUEL," At the Harvard Film Archive, through June 30.
Luis Buñuel was almost always subversive and frequently uproarious, but
I'd hesitate to say that he was often charming. His movies are studded with
bitter ironies, they can be baffling (in whole or in part), and they devalue
most of the elements we resolutely bourgeois viewers tend to look for -- like
character, performance, plot, high style, polish. He attacked the Catholic
Church over and over (he was raised in Spain by the Jesuits), and his films can
sometimes be seen as parables about the repressive Franco regime, but his major
target was the middle-class expectations of his audiences. So the appropriate
response to many of his movies is probably both amusement and bemusement, a
baffled admiration of his refusal to buckle to the demands of popular narrative
filmmaking -- baffled because the shrug with which he seems to throw sections
of his pictures away (like the final sequences in his superb 1965 short film
Simon of the Desert and in the famous Belle de jour two years
later) is so much in opposition to his savvy and abilities that it can feel
like a slashing of his own canvases. He may be the only great moviemaker who
seemed to care so little about technique so much of the time -- and that
paradox is, of course, part of the fascination of watching his pictures.
The Harvard Film Archive series, which plays throughout June, is the first
major Buñuel retrospective in the Boston area in a long time, and
despite its omissions -- The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie is
conspicuously absent, as are El and Nazarín, and
especially his great 1952 adaptation of The Adventures of Robinson
Crusoe -- the 14 selections provide a rich sampling of Buñuel in all
three of his phases and all his forms. He had a very strange career. His early
short films -- Un chien andalou and L'âge d'or
(double-billed June 12), made with Salvador Dalí, and Las Hurdes
(otherwise known as Land Without Bread, June 13) -- are modernist
classics; you wouldn't dream of designing a course in the history of world
cinema and leaving them out.
The Dalí collaborations, made in 1928 and 1930, are audacious,
poker-faced pieces of pure surrealism. In Un chien andalou, a man
(played by Buñuel himself) slices a woman's eye with a razor as clouds
obscure the moon outside his window -- a scene of gothic horror that's undercut
by its utter affectlessness and the hilarious lack of consequence this violent
act produces in terms of character or narrative. And in L'âge d'or
the loud coupling of a man and woman interrupts a solemn ceremony in a
graveyard, where a pair of skeletons (one in a general's hat, one in a
cardinal's) are the objects of official obeisance. Although pulled apart, the
couple can't keep away from each other; later he crashes her parents' dinner
party and, after belting her mother for spilling wine on his boiled shirt, he
lures his inamorata to the garden to resume their lovemaking while the other
guests applaud a local orchestra made up partially of glaring, violin-playing
priests. (L'âge d'or inspired Henry Miller to write an article
called "The Golden Age" in which he claimed, "They have called Buñuel
everything -- traitor, anarchist, pervert, defamer, iconoclast. But lunatic
they dare not call him.")
You'd imagine that these films, and the shocking, unforgettable Las
Hurdes -- a 1932 documentary about a mountain region of Spain so poor and
backward that its nightmarish reality blurs the line between realism and
surrealism -- would have catapulted Buñuel into an astonishing career as
an avant-garde artist. But instead he worked as a dubber and a producer, went
to Hollywood during the Spanish Civil War to advise on pro-Loyalist pictures --
a project that came to an abrupt end when Franco defeated the Loyalists -- and
finally got a job at the Museum of Modern Art. He didn't get back to directing
his own movies until he went to Mexico in 1947, and the films he made there,
until he moved his operations to France in the mid '60s, are a curious mix.
Some are potboilers (like Illusion Travels by Streetcar, June 16 and 17,
and his adaptation of Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights), offering
little evidence of his wit, his obsessions, or his cool satirist's style.
Others, like The Criminal Life of Archibaldo de la Cruz (June 18 and
19), Viridiana (June 23), The Exterminating Angel (June 19 and
21), and the 45-minute Simon of the Desert (June 13), are distinctive
black comedies that no one else could possibly have made, though they're
sometimes executed with such carelessness that the experience of watching them
tends to be simultaneously invigorating and exasperating. Two (Los
olvidados, June 1 and 4, and The Adventures of Robinson Crusoe) are
masterpieces.
Finally, in 1967, he began to make his movies in color, with a sudden,
unlooked-for visual dazzle and some of the most glamorous actors in Europe
(Catherine Deneuve, Delphine Seyrig, Bulle Ogier, Pierre Clementi, Michel
Piccoli, in addition to his favorite actor, the slyly elegant Spaniard Fernando
Rey). Except for The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie, the HFA series
includes all of these: Belle de jour (June 20 and 21), The Milky
Way (June 20), Tristana (June 13 and 14), The Phantom of
Liberty (June 12 and 14), and That Obscure Object of Desire (June
27, 28, and 30).
The common element in all these movies except for the potboilers is the
unremitting use of irony, though it appears in different forms. In
Tristana, the beautiful heroine (Deneuve) deflowered by her aging
guardian (Rey) loses her leg to a disease that almost takes her life, and the
clump of her wooden leg makes her even more desirable to him. She also becomes
a mean, bitter-tongued survivor, like Mattie Silver in Edith Wharton's Ethan
Frome. (The film is a rather dull parable, but it's briefly enlivened by
these final scenes.) In Simon of the Desert, the saintly Simon (Claudio
Brook) stands on a pillar, preaching to the assembled people and performing the
occasional miracle to help them out, but they're so used to him that his
generosity elicits no gratitude, in fact no response stronger than blasé
assessment. A thief whose hands were chopped off as punishment moans that in
his debilitated state he can't feed his children; when Simon restores his
hands, the first action he takes with them is to shove his curious son. In
Los olvidados, a brutal depiction of ghetto life among the children of
Mexico City, the ironies are partly Dickensian and partly Marxist. In one
scene, we see the delighted faces of children on a merry-go-round; then the
camera pulls back to reveal that their entertainment has been purchased by the
labor of other children, human pack horses who trudge to make the apparatus
move.
Los olvidados is one of the few Buñuels that doesn't contain any
of his trademark narrative tricks -- his favorite way of upsetting bourgeois
expectations. In The Exterminating Angel, an aristocrat gives a dinner
party and for some reason the guests find they can't leave. The end of Belle
de jour, a tale of a chic Parisian housewife who takes a day job as a
hooker, resolves nothing: it throws the story into an endless cycle, like the
end of the great British horror anthology Dead of Night (though for
reasons that are a lot less clear than they are in Dead of Night). The
joke of The Phantom of Liberty is that there's no throughline and no
focal set of characters: each episode leads calmly to another, the anecdotal
scenes spelling each other for our attention like vaguely related paintings in
an eclectic gallery. That Obscure Object of Desire has the same plot
line as the Sternberg-Dietrich The Devil Is a Woman, but for reasons
Buñuel never makes clear the beauty who tempts and taunts the
protagonist (Fernando Rey) is played by two different -- and extremely
different-looking -- actresses, Carole Bouquet and Angela Molina. The Milky
Way has only the tiniest wisp of a frame -- a pilgrimage -- linking its
sketches, which alternate between the modern day and the 18th century.
Almost all of these movies display Buñuel's love of surrealist imagery,
which never deserted him. A coffin slithers across the desert sand in Simon
of the Desert and Satan (in the form of the beautiful Silvia Pinal) steps
out of it. A disembodied hand rolls across a plate in The Exterminating
Angel. Tristana envisions her seducer's head as the clapper of the town's
church bell.
The single surrealist sequence in Los olvidados is the most stunning
scene in the film. Pedro (Alfonso Mejía), banished by his mother (Estela
Inda), returns home to beg her forgiveness, but she refuses to feed him and
sends him away -- mostly because she has begun to sleep with his friend, Jaibo
(Roberto Cobo), and her guilt multiplies her battery of resentments against her
son. In Pedro's dream, he asks her why she wouldn't give him any meat, and she
responds by bringing him a side of raw beef dripping blood while Jaibo
materializes from under the bed. Buñuel employs this dream sequence to
articulate the horrors of Pedro's existence, and here (as, I think, in all his
surrealist images) his artistry works in tandem with his unflinching ironist's
gaze and his subversive's fearlessness. The combination can be a heady tonic --
a sharp kick in the ass and a fast, deep gulp of fresh air.